Home > Uncategorized > Peyton Manning Out of Indy?

Peyton Manning Out of Indy?

A recent story on ESPN detailed the changing culture in the Indianapolis Colts organization, specifically revolving around star quarterback Peyton Manning. Manning, who missed the entire season with a nerve problem in his neck, watched as the only team he has ever played for struggled to a 2-14 season, earning them the first overall pick in the NFL draft in April. Following the Colts’ disastrous season, owner Jim Irsay fired vice president Bill Polian and general manager Chris Polian. Just a short time ago, Irsay continued cleaning house when he fired head coach Jim Caldwell.

All of the changes have taken their toll on Manning, who, at age 35, may be on his way out of Indianapolis to make way for likely #1 overall pick, quarterback Andrew Luck of Stanford. Much of the concern focused on the $28 million bonus that the Colts owe Manning in early March. Before this past season, there was very little question that Manning would receive his bonus; however, with his health a key issue, the Colts may not want to spend that kind of money on someone that may not play much longer.

This is why they should.

There’s a guy in Green Bay named Aaron Rodgers. You may know him from his Super Bowl victory last season, and his MVP-caliber season in 2011. Rodgers did not get the opportunity to start until a few seasons ago, because Brett Favre led the Packers until he left for the New York Jets in 2008. In the mean time, Rodgers had three full seasons to learn the craft of the quarterback position under one of the best of all time. Four years after he took over the starting role, Rodgers has led the Packers to three playoff appearances, a Super Bowl victory, and on a personal note, three Pro Bowl appearances. Why can’t this tactic work for the Colts and Andrew Luck?

Peyton Manning is 35 and is coming off of a unique injury, but assuming he returns to the field, Manning is still one of the best and smartest quarterbacks in the league. Watching Manning read defenses, call audibles, and essentially run his own offense is like watching Pablo Picasso paint. In my honest opinion, if anyone can train a quarterback to lead a team to glory, it is Peyton Manning.

The big problem, though, is Peyton Manning. Is he worth it? Personally, I believe so. But that’s up to the Colts to decide.

  1. January 25, 2012 at 11:16 pm

    It’s always a shame to see a legend being treated like this, but such is business.

    If Peyton does leave (or get kicked out), where do you see him going/where would you like to see him go?

    • January 26, 2012 at 1:11 am

      If Peyton leaves, I would say Arizona. They would probably do what they did with Kurt Warner in the twilight of his career, and then struggle for 3 years until another former big-name quarterback gets let go. Call the Cardinals the Florida of NFL quarterbacks, I guess.

      What I would like to see Peyton do eventually, whether it be an immediate retirement or not, would be to come back as the offensive coordinator for the Colts (or any other team for that matter). The way he reads defenses, figures out what his offense can and can’t do against a defense on any particular play is amazing, and he could definitely put that to good use for a team.

  2. Nate
    February 2, 2012 at 1:04 pm

    San Fran needs to go after Peyton if he leaves. For whatever reason (which I still personally believe is Alex Smith), the 49ers completed 1 pass to a receiver in the NFC Championship, to Crabtree for a grand total of 3 yards. No third down conversions until the final play of regulation. They should have won the game even after Kyle Williams’ first botched punt (and the second would never have happened). Whether it’s the fault of Alex Smith or the receivers, Peyton Manning changes that situation completely. That’s what the 49ers need to win a super bowl

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: